Short Answers:
1)
Evan Smith
experienced a heart attack in the emergency room of Baptist Memorial Hospital
after being given a dose of penicillin for a sore throat. Smith sued the
attending physician as well as the hospital. The hospital called itself a
full-service hospital with emergency room facilities. Baptist Memorial did not
consider the doctors to be its agents. For tax and accounting purpose the
doctors were not treated as employees of the hospital. Based on this
information, discuss whether the doctors who treated patients in the emergency
room were agents of the hospital.
2)
Justin Jones
suffered from genital herpes and sought treatment from Dr. Steven Baisch of
Region West Pediatric Services. A nurse assistant, Jennifer Hallgren, who was a
Region West employee, told her friends and some of Jones’s friendsabout Jones’s condition. This was a
violation of the Region West employee handbook, which required employees to
maintain the confidentiality of patients’ records. Jones filed suit in a
federal district court against Region West, among others, alleging that Region
West should be held liable for its employee’s actions on the basis of Respondeat
Superior. On what basis might the court hold that Region West was not
liable for Hallgren’s acts? Discuss fully.
3)
California
Consumers Co. purchased from S.L.Coker an ice distributing business in the city
of Santa Monica. In the purchase agreement, Coker agreed that he would not
engage in the business of selling or distributing ice either directly or
indirectly in Santa Monica, so long as the purchasers or any later purchasers
remained in the business. Imperial Ice Co. acquired the ice distributing
business from California Consumers. Coker subsequently began selling ice in the
same territory. The ice was supplied to him by a company owned by Rosner and
Matheson on very attractive terms, because they wanted to break into the
territory.Imperial Ice sued to obtain an injunction to restrain Coker
from violating his original contract.Did Rosner induce Coker to violate
his contract and were they therefore liable for the tort of wrongful
interference with contractual relations? Explain.
4)
As a beginning
songwriter and performer, you are convinced that a certain model of guitar is
what you need to turn the musical world on its ear. Chick’s Music store
advertises the item but because the store is sold out when you get there, you
accept a rain check signed by Daria, one of the employees. You return to the
store one month later, but Chuck refuses to honor the rain check. Under the UCC
would you win your suit to enforce the contract? Why or Why not?
5)
On May 1, you
contract orally with Johnny,a salesperson with Keyboards Emporium, to buy
for $450 an electric organ for your personal enjoyment with delivery to occur
on July 1. On May 15, you ask for delivery on June 1 and Johnny agrees. But
delivery does not occur on June 1. The store later tells you delivery will be
on July 1 as agreed in the first place. Under the UCC which delivery date is
binding? Explain. Would there be a difference under common law contracts?
Explain
ESSAY
1)
John H. Surratt
was one of John Wilkes Booth’s alleged accomplices in the murder of President
Lincoln.On April 29, 1865, the Secretary of War issued and caused to be
published in newspapers the following proclamation: “$25,000 reward for the
apprehension of John H. Surratt and liberal rewards for any information that
leads to the arrest of John H. Surratt.”On November 24, 1865, President
Johnson revoked the reward and published the revocation in the
newspapers.Henry B. St. Marie learned of the reward but left for Rome
prior to its revocation.In Rome, St. Marie discovered Surratt’s
whereabouts.In April, 1866 unaware that the reward had been revoked, he
reported this information to U.S. officials. Based on this information Surratt
was arrested. The government denied St. Marie the reward.
a.
Should Marie
have received the reward? Explain. Be sure to include in the discussion any theories of recovery Marie
would argue as well as those the government
would use to defeat Marie.
b.
If Marie were
to get the award, would he be entitled to the full $25,000? Explain.
c.
What if this
had occurred in the year 2010 and the reward was published not in a newspaper but on the Internet as was the
revocation. Would the result be the same? Would it be the same if the award was published on the Internet, but the
revocation in the newspaper?
Explain
2)
Stephen Brooks
was employed as a sales representative for the Bob King Mitsubishi car
dealership.Reba Stanley, age eighteen, met with Brooks to test drive a
Mitsubishi pickup truck. During the test drive, Brooks assaulted Stanley “by
touching and grabbing her arms, hands, groin area, and breasts. He also exposed
his genitals and placed her hand on his private parts.” When they returned from
the test drive, Brooks took her to the Mitsubishi service department “and
exposed himself again and tried to force her to touch him.”Stanley was
able to free herself and left the dealership. Brooks was later convicted on
charges arising out of the incident. Stanley sued both Brooks and the car
dealership, claiming the she suffered intentional infliction of emotional
distress.
a.
What must
Stanley prove in order to win her case and why.
b.
The dealership
argued that the case against them should be dropped as they were not
responsible for Brook’s actions, and asked the court to grant a motion for
summary judgment.The defense argues that the motion should be denied
under the doctrine of “respondeat superior”. Should the court grant the
motion? If so why or if not why not?





