Compare effectiveness of splinting
versus surgery for carpal
A randomized trial was designed to
compare the effectiveness of splinting versus surgery in the treatment of
carpal tunnel syndrome. Results, given in the below table, are based on
evaluations made one year after treatment.
Using a 0.05 level of significance
(? = 0.05), test the claim that success is independent of the type of
treatment:
Successful Treatment Unsuccessful Treatment
Splint Treatment 60 25
Surgery Treatment 70 10
#7a) Write the null hypothesis
(Ho) for this test:
#7b) Write the alternative
hypothesis (Ha) for this test:
#8a) Compute the degrees of
freedom associated with this test:
#8b) Find the critical value:
#9a) Write the rule of rejection
(decision rule) using the test statistic and critical value
#9b) Write the rule of rejection
(decision rule) using the p-value and alpha
#10a) Compute the Test Statistic
(Ï?2):
Was the above computed by-hand,
Minitab, or other (if other, please specify)?
#10b) Compute the associated
p-value:
#11) What if your statistical
result (i.e., are you rejection or not rejecting the null hypothesis)?
#12) Based on your results from
Question #11, which treatment, if any, is more effective? (If you conclude one
treatment is superior, state your reasons – beyond your answer to Question #11
– for your choice).





