ScholarMatic | 24/7 Homework Help

ScholarMatic Will Help You Write Your Essays and Term Papers

Answered » You can buy a ready-made answer or pick a professional tutor to order an original one.

UNIONS AND COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

by | Nov 30, 2023 | questions

UNIONS AND COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

AN EXAMPLE 2

The defeat of Proposition 75 in California is an interesting case study. The proposal would have prohibited public employee unions from using dues or fees for political contributions unless the employee provides annual written permission on a specified form. It was one of four centerpiece proposals of Governor Schwarzenegger just two years after his popular election after deposing Governor Gray Davis. Another proposal that was defeated was California Proposition 74 limiting teacher rights. It would have increased the length of time required before a teacher could become a permanent employee from two complete consecutive school years to five complete consecutive school years. It also would have authorized school boards to dismiss a permanent teaching employee who receives two consecutive unsatisfactory performance evaluations. Both propositions started out heavily favored to win by margins deficits of 23 and 29% respectively. Yet enormous union support, in league with the Democratic Party, ultimately defeated the agenda along with all other proposals on the ballot by handy margins. This particular case is an example of unions as protectors of labor and punishers of political leaders in the political arena, and as partners with a political party. An alternate and more recent example is about Measures L and M in Riverside County in 2010. The public safety unions wanted to protect pension rights that were secured when the economy was booming, in light of the ballooning state budget deficit after the start of the Great Recession of 2008. They framed the ballot as a protection of the survivors of public service workers killed in action, although the real force was to make it nearly impossible to legislatively reduce public safety pension rights in the future by normal legislative action. The Board of Supervisors framed an alternate ballot measure which would also protect survivor rights of fallen public safety personnel, but would allow legislative reform of pensions by the legislature. Although the public safety pension protection measure passed, the alternative proposal did also, but by a much larger margin. Because the two propositions were competitive, the anti-union measure went into effect and the pro-union measure was suspended. What the public gives, it can take away…

3

VIEWS OF UNIONS

Public employees and public managers have both positive and negative views about unions in the public sector. Environments with strong unions generally enjoy more benefits, higher salaries for line employees, more protection against capricious or arbitrary actions by management, and more voice in matters related to personnel issues. On the negative side, employees themselves are often concerned about high union dues, unresponsive labor leaders, unflattering stereotypes associated with unions, and questionable benefits. Also, some feel that unions promote one-size-fits-all employee strategies and ultimately mediocrity. Some prefer representation by professional associations over unions. Administrators often have more negative views, such as a tendency to push up costs, reduce productivity, impede needed organizational change, and place employee rights over client and citizen needs. They may also feel that strong unions seek to introduce confrontation in order to justify their existence, and may promote an adversarial and legalistic environment. Public perceptions of public sector unions just a few years ago was largely evenly split with relatively low negative perceptions. Since the recession put public sector budgets under withering pressure, popular support of public unions has plummeted and strongly negative

4

INTERVIEW WITH CHANI BEEMAN, LABOR RELATIONS SPECIALIST

Currently with Riverside Community College, formerly with CSUSB

Question 1

COMMENT: THE DUAL ROLES OF UNIONS 5

Question 4

6

At their best, unions are a type of workplace democracy. The prospect of unionization prods organizations to treat their employees well to keep unions out, or, when unionized, to treat them well to avoid conflict. In some cases they can bring fragmented groups together and be highly collaborative. For example, many unions in the 2008 recession encouraged members to take furloughs in order to preserve the jobs of many employees until the economy could recover enough to refund those jeopardized positions. Yet no matter whether labor-management relations (LMR) is at its best or worst, it is an important topic in human resource management because of the enormous role it plays in organizational climate and employee satisfaction, management success, and organizational productivity.

7

COMMENT BY CHANI BEEMAN: THE POSITIVE ROLE OF UNIONS

PARADOXES 8

Some paradoxes

Trends

Administration

The paradoxes of unionizing are numerous so I will only give a few examples. High productivity work environments depend on trust and collaboration, but unions often encourage litigiousness and conflict; collective bargaining ensures employee rights in general, but often at the expense of top performers and to the benefit of the weakest performers; unions may increase work democracy but may diminish democratic accountability to the people’s elected representatives; and while unions work to protect employee rights, sometimes non-union members enjoy the benefits of union successes without the expense.

TRENDS 9

Union representation in general has been declining since the 1950s when it represented approximately 35% of the workforce. At the time, government unionization was significantly smaller and less important. However, as the percentage represented by unions has steadily declined in the private sector to about 7.5 percent today, public sector representation increased substantially in the 1960s through the 1980s, and has leveled off since. Today, union representation stands at about 36 percent and private sector rates stand at about 7.5%. During this time period, federal union rates have dropped but state and local level rates have increased.

AGENCIES AND TERMS 10

Some agencies, terms and laws are critical in understanding LMR:

FLRA: Federal Labor Relations Authority created under the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 controls federal labor relations.

PERBs: state administrative agencies typically charged with determining appropriate bargaining units, overseeing certification elections, and resolving unfair labor practices.

NLRB: National Labor Relations Board oversees private sector union creation and unfair labor disputes.

Yellow dog contract (made illegal under the Norris-LaGuardia Act of 1932): An agreement signed by workers before they are hired, stipulating that they would not join a union after they are hired.

NLRA: National Labor Relations Act; also known as the Wagner Act of 1935. Set up the NLRB and lists unfair labor practices.

Taft-Hartley Act: added dispute resolution to the NLRA; allowed states to pass right-to-work laws thus restricting union growth in some areas. Right to work states include all Southern states and most of the states in the West not on the coast with the exceptions of New Mexico, Colorado, and Montana.

Union shop: Employee must join the union after a certain number of days specified in the collective bargaining agreement.

Agency shop: Employees is not required to join the union but must contribute a service charge to cover collective bargaining, grievance processes and arbitration costs.

Impasse means that labor and management negotiations have stalled and that a third party will be called in unless a strike is called. Public sector strikes occur in the U.S. but are not common today. Third-party impasse procedures are roughly divided into mediation and arbitration but they have slightly different meanings in different contexts. Mediation can refer to any third party bargaining, but when used more specifically, it refers to third party interactions that are nonbinding. One form of mediation is factfinding which in which the third party conducts research and hearings, and provides nonbinding recommendations. Arbitration suggests that the third party has more power. The most common type is final-offer arbitration, in which the parties provide positions from which the arbitrator selects the one that s/he thinks is the most reasonable. This is intended to push the parties to the center. It is also commonly called binding arbitration. Med-Arb is when the third party is to begin with mediation, but is empowered to move to arbitration if mediation fails.

COMMENT: CHANI BEEMAN ON OPEN AND AGENCY SHOPS 11

Question 10

PUBLIC-PRIVAE DIFFERENCES 12

A word about the differences between private and public unions is also in order. Public union benefits are provided via civil service statutes and the scope of negotiations is narrow. Private union negotiations are broader and much more of the employment contract is on the table. The authority of multilateral bargaining in the public sector is dispersed and involves many players. In the private sector it is largely a two party process. The public sector tends to have monopolistic characteristics so substitution for services such as fire protection is difficult. The private sector tends to be more open to market forces and substitution of services by consumers. Therefore, public sector strikes are generally restricted and often illegal under responsibility theory. Generally private sector strikes are a legal part of negotiations. The doctrine of sovereignty implies that the shared governance involved in public employment makes it inappropriate for a disproportionate union say whereas the doctrine of sovereignty does not apply to the private sector. Ultimately, decisions have an economic impact but are based on political criteria, whereas the private sector decisions may have a political/ public relations impact but are largely economic decisions.

REPRESENTATION AND COLLECTIVE BARGAINING 13

Collective bargaining: definition and framing factors

Organizing for bargaining: certifying the agent and picking the team

Bargaining

Administering the contract

Collective bargaining is the process whereby labor and management representatives meet to set terms and conditions of employment for personnel in the bargaining unit. Factors that affect the process include: the nature of the bilateral relationship, the type of union security provisions, the kind of administrative arrangements, the range of unfair labor practices, and the existence of dispute resolution or impasse procedures. The bargaining process is divided into three phases: organizing to bargain, bargaining, and administering the contract.

Bargaining units must be certified by the appropriate body: the NLRB, FLRA, or a PERB. Representation elections are carefully monitored after initial petitions for elections meet a predetermined critical mass. It is also possible to decertify a bargaining agent as well. When the bargaining unit has been selected, they select the representatives as does management. Both sides try to select people who are articulate, strong-willed, and tough when needed.

Bargaining is often highly scripted in terms of locations, issues, and the provision of a series of proposals, from the most optimistic to one that is likely to be agreed-upon. Both sides must negotiate in good faith, or at least appear to do so, should the decision go to impasse. Failure to negotiate in good faith might be the unwillingness of one side to meet or to put alternative proposals on the table. Most collective bargaining is a type of distributive bargaining in which there is a win-lose mentality, high hostility, and adversarial relations. However, principled negotiations or integrative bargaining stresses identification of common ground, focuses on cooperative problem-solving, and works best in an atmosphere of mutual trust. It encourages separation of people from the problem, focuses on interests rather than positions, invents options for mutual gain, and insists on objective criteria. Impasse procedures include mediation, fact-finding, and various types of arbitration.

The principal mechanism in contract administration is the grievance procedure. Two key players in contract administration are the union steward and the first line supervisor. When issues cannot be resolved at this level, formal grievances may be filed that trigger due process proceedings.

HOSTILITY VERSUS HARMONY (PROBLEM-SOLVING BARGAINING) 14

Doctrine of hostility

Doctrine of harmony

In a market system, it is competition and contracts that are free to rise and fall at will. That is less appropriate in a public sector setting, in which political sovereignty and monopoly tend to prevail. Many have suggested that the adversarial, conflictual and confrontational style of bargaining so common in the private sector is far less appropriate, and, in the long-term, effective in the public sector. Problem-solving bargaining discussion is resolution oriented, leading to mutually agreeable and beneficial answers to common problems. Problem solving bargaining repudiates the antagonistic stance of the traditional model and seeks to forge long-lasting agreements based on the needs of all stakeholders. There are several courses of action that accomplish this: honestly appraise what needs to be changed, inform stakeholders of these basic needs, encourage exchange of possible solutions, and reach agreements on specific solutions. While not common, it is no longer rare. Problem solving bargaining got a strong foothold at the federal level in the Clinton administration, although much of that progress was rescinded in the Presidency of George W. Bush. There are examples across the United States as illustrated in the textbook exhibit called “Five Examples of State and Local Governments Engaged with Unions in Cooperative Problem Solving.” Indeed, some countries such as Japan and Germany have much more harmonic relations as a matter of cultural disposition, and in fact have high efficiency rates at the same time.

COMMENT: CHANI BEEMAN 15

SOME TIPS FOR MANAGERS

Question 14

CONCLUSION 16

The importance of unions may diminish somewhat over time, but they have forever changed the public sector culture and law already, and will always be an important factor in most public sector environments.

ScholarMatic: Explanation & Answer

Your ready answer from a verified tutor is just a click away for as little as $14.99


  

Click Order Now to get 100% Original Answer Customized to your instructions!

HOME TO CERTIFIED WRITERS

Why Place An Order With Us?

  • Certified Editors
  • 24/7 Customer Support
  • Profesional Research
  • Easy to Use System Interface
  • Student Friendly Pricing

Have a similar question?

PLAGIRAISM FREE PAPERS

All papers we provide are well-researched, properly formatted and cited.

TOP QUALITY

All papers we provide are well-researched, properly formatted and cited.

HIGHLY SECURED

All papers we provide are well-researched, properly formatted and cited.

ScholarMatic: Get Started

Assignment Writing Service

Feel safe and secure when placing an order on our portal!
Fruitful cooperation begins with solid guarantees, and we are professional enough to promise perfect results. Let’s get it started!