documentary entitled “Alaska Gold.”The documentary can be found at:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/alaska-gold/
As you watch the documentary take
special note of decisions or issues that involve moral or ethical
considerations regarding the environment.From your notes, focus
particularly on one case where a critical decision about the environment
needs to be made.Using this case, explain what each major approach to
environmental ethics would require us to do in the situation (the
approaches are: the free market approach, Baxter’s Spheres of Freedom
and Sagoff’s civic values.)
notes attached
Baxter and sagoff on environmental ethics
3 Approaches to the Environmental Issues
Free market approach: allow the mechanism of the free-market to determine what to do – pursuing efficiency or wealth-maximization.
Baxter’s Spheres of Freedom: maximize satisfaction of human preferences without treating anyone as a mere means.
Sagoff’s civic values approach: protect those cultural, historical, aesthetic and moral values that matter to communities, not collections of individuals.
Baxter and the Spheres of Freedom Principle
Baxter’s view about our duties to the environment is based on a principle he uses to resolve all moral and political issues.
The Spheres of Freedom Principle: every person should be free to do whatever s/he wishes in contexts where his/her actions do not interfere with the interests of other human beings.
Example: it is okay for me to litter so long as it does not interfere with the interests of other humans.
Consequences of the Spheres of Freedom Principle
The only role of government and the legislation government passes is to keep humans from interfering with the interests of other humans wherever possible.
Laws that prevent individuals from harming themselves (but not others), sometimes called paternalist laws, have no place in a just society.
Government must enact legislation that will prevent some members of society from harming others through pollution or other acts/effects.
What Value Does The Environment Have?
Only human beings have inherent moral worth.
Thus, any non-human animal, plants or non-living thing has no value except insofar as it is valuable to human beings.
Example: if no one were to value an ecosystem in Indiana, then it would have no value at all.
But to the extent that a human does (or perhaps would) find something valuable that thing has value.
Making Decisions with Baxter
In determining what to do when it comes to environmental policies and decision making a business owner (like anyone else) must:
-…





