Please read
the attached case abstract and prepare your write up that (1) summarizes the
factual situation, (2) identifies the issues/questions in the case, (3)
discusses the relevant accounting standards and practices (FASB, others), and
(4) provides your opinion as to the reserves. There is no minimum number of
pages for this assignment. However I am looking for a detailed analysis and
discussion that adequately answers the above questions. 5 pages paper
Conservative Recognition or Cookie Jar Reserves?
by
Lorri
Carpenter, CPA/PFS
Aunt Amelia has no accounting expertise
and is interested in meeting projections and keeping the Wall Street analysts
happy. Was her nephew Nick making too
big a deal out of legitimate business practice?
Abstract
Nick O’Brian begins work at his family’s software company and quickly
finds evidence of revenue recognition questions. Should he ignore them or
should he recommend that the audit committee be notified? If he chooses the
latter, an important upcoming product launch could be ruined.
Background
Figuratively
speaking, O’Brian Software’s books smelled a little funny. Nick O’Brian, newest
member of the accounting department, pushed the stack of financial statements
away and ran a hand through his already rumpled hair. He had a feeling the
numbers he’d been analyzing wouldn’t pass what his professors had called the
“sniff test.” Nick rubbed his eyes and wondered if he was overreacting. After
all, his Aunt Amelia, the company’s founder, was the most honest person he
knew–though she would be the first to admit she was no accounting expert.
Nick believed
the person his aunt relied on–Lee Marchetti, O’Brian Software’s chief
financial officer, a man with years of experience in finance and
accounting–was equally honest. Judging from the documentation Nick had found
in the accounting files, Lee certainly kept a tight watch over every aspect of
O’Brian’s finances.
In addition,
from what Nick had learned in his position as junior internal auditor at
O’Brian, the company’s accounting controls were effective. Though family
members still owned the majority of the stock, decisions regarding material
aspects of the financial statements were discussed with the audit committee of
the board of directors. The board itself was made up of five very respected
members of the business community.
And, to top off
the case for overreaction on his part, the financials had received a clean
opinion from the outside auditors for each of the three years the company had
been listed on the stock exchange.
But he still
thought those numbers had an odor … and might well be misleading investors.
Nick was determined O’Brian Software would never find itself in the same
situation as so many companies these days. He was too proud of what his aunt
had created to allow a Securities and Exchange Commission investigation to
happen.
He leaned back
in his chair and remembered when O’Brian had been little more than a dream of
Aunt Amelia’s. She’d started out in her spare bedroom, providing software
consulting services to local businesses. Next, she’d expanded into the
development and sale of custom software systems. Then, with family members
recruited as her sales force, she’d begun selling the licenses to her software.
At that point she realized the company was headed for an eventual initial
public offering. With typical foresight, she’d decided experienced management
was needed. Lee Marchetti had come on board as CFO.
Now, five years
since its inception, and three years after going public, O’Brian Software
earned millions in revenues from Aunt Amelia’s initial product licenses, along
with fees for maintenance, support and technical training, and consulting and
development services. With the next step–the release of BrainWave, an
innovative, multi-dimensional software system compatible with industry standard
platforms–O’Brian would surge ahead in another growth spurt. Wall Street buzz
had the company poised on the forefront of the technology sector. Yes, Nick
thought, O’Brian Software had definitely expanded beyond Aunt Amelia’s wildest
expectations. Yet in many ways the company was as family oriented as it had
been when it started. Nick was living proof.
Though his aunt
had officially hired him only after his college graduation two months earlier,
he’d been part of the company since the day she founded it. He knew Aunt Amelia
expected him to work his way up the management ladder. It was a challenge he
was looking forward to.
Asking Questions
But right now
there was a question he needed answered. And since Aunt Amelia was less than
enthusiastic about accounting, the person to ask was O’Brian’s CFO, Lee
Marchetti. Nick grabbed the stack of papers, and headed out the door of his
cubicle.
“Always glad to
answer questions, Nick.” Lee Marchetti shuffled the papers on top of his walnut
desk off to one side. “But I have to say you’ve picked a difficult topic to
start with. Software revenue recognition
is complex. Throw in the mix of application development and consulting services
we have at O’Brian, and we could be here for days discussing it.”
“I’ll try not
to take up that much of your time,” Nick said, with a grin. He leaned forward,
his hands on his knees. “I think I understand the general idea of multiple
element transactions. Basically, revenue is broken down between product and
services. O’Brian recognizes revenue on the software if the sale is distinct
from the service portion. Right so far?”
Lee nodded.
“Right. When we enter contracts involving a combination of software and
consulting services, we end up with revenue deferral. And of course, as you
know, we defer revenue for other reasons, as well. We have reserves for product
returns and warranties, among others.”
“Which leads to
my question,” Nick said. “O’Brian Software has a significant amount of unearned
revenue sitting on the balance sheet. It seems to me we’ve been overly
conservative in estimating the amount of income we’ve been deferring.”
Lee blinked,
than chuckled. “Conservatism in financial reporting is generally considered a
good thing, Nick. In fact, most folks are concerned about just the opposite
effect–they worry companies report too much income. You’re saying you think we
haven’t been reporting enough?”
“I’m just
trying to follow the methodology we’re using,” Nick replied. He could tell he’d
surprised Lee with his question, so he went on. “You have a lot more experience
than I do, Lee, I know that. Heck, Aunt Amelia told me you’ve been running
companies since before I was born, and I know how much she relies on you. But
I’m worried. Overly conservative reporting could leave the impression we’re
trying to create cookie jar reserves. With all the corporate accounting
problems in the news lately, the last thing we need is to face rumors of
suspect accounting. Especially with BrainWave almost ready for release.”
Lee’s smile
vanished. “You’re exactly right–we definitely do not need any hint of
problems. Now or at any time.” He eyed Nick, his face grim. “Despite what most
people believe, accounting is not an exact science. A lot of judgment is
involved.”
“I understand,”
Nick said. “There’s no clear line spelling out exactly what’s right and what’s
wrong. But don’t you agree that since O’Brian is affected by the cyclical
buying patterns in our industry it might seem we have incentive to smooth our
earnings?”
“I can assure
you the accounting practices here at O’Brian will never cast doubt on the
integrity of this company’s financial statements. Our deferrals and estimates
are well documented, and in accordance with SEC rules.” Lee stood up. “Now, if
you’ll excuse me, I have a meeting with our bankers.”
Meeting with Aunt Amelia
“Nick, you know
my specialty is software, not accounting.” Though Aunt Amelia was facing him,
Nick could see her fingers were still dancing across her keyboard. For as long
as he could remember, she’d been an expert at doing two things at once. He’d
always thought her drive was the main reason O’Brian Software was a success.
She tipped her head toward the papers he held and added, “If you want to
discuss a problem with your PC software, I’m your woman. But financial
statements–if you have questions on those, you’ll need to talk to Lee
Marchetti.”
“I did,” Nick
replied. “I’m surprised he didn’t mention it to you. In fact, my talk with him
is one reason I’m here.”
His aunt was
startled enough to stop her keystroking. “You sound serious.”
“I am,” Nick
said. Confident he had her full attention, he settled into the chair opposite
her desk and repeated the discussion he’d had with Lee.
When he was
finished, she was frowning. “I’m not sure I understand why you’re concerned,
Nick. As I’ve said many times, I don’t know much about accounting. But I know
enough to grasp one thing–we’re not underreporting expenses, or inflating our
income by prematurely recognizing revenue. In fact, it sounds like O’Brian
Software is doing precisely the opposite of what most companies get in trouble
for.”
“My point
exactly.” Nick tapped the statements with his forefinger. “These reports are
supposed to provide useful information, Aunt Amelia. Being too conservative is
simply the opposite side of being too aggressive–neither position gives an
accurate picture. In fact, they may even give investors an unrealistic view of
our actual financial situation.” He paused. “Have you looked at the financial
statements since O’Brian went public?”
She made a
sound halfway between a snort and a chuckle. “Please, Nick, I’m sure you know
the answer.”
He smiled at
her, rose, and set the statements down on her desk. “Well, take a look now.” He
shuffled the pages, pointed out numbers. “Our growth and revenue are fairly
smooth, and always upward. It’s kind of unusual in a new company, especially a
new technology company, wouldn’t you say?”
“I certainly
know the software business has ups and downs,” Aunt Amelia said. “All
businesses do. But I still don’t quite see the problem. After all, we’re
meeting our earnings projections, aren’t we? We’re keeping our analysts happy,
aren’t we?”
“Consistently,”
Nick agreed. “But I’m not sure we’re doing it based on economic performance. In
effect, what’s happening is we’re understating profits when times are good, and
building artificial reserves we can use in lean times.”
The Dilemma
“You’re saying
we’re playing games with the numbers. That is
a serious charge, Nick.” Aunt Amelia looked up and studied him. “I have
complete confidence in Lee. But if we’re doing something improper, I want to
get to the bottom of it. Is this a problem I should take to the auditing
committee?”
Nick had been
sure of himself until she asked. Now he hesitated. He was convinced O’Brian
Software’s financial statements were not presenting an accurate picture to
investors. But, as Lee Marchetti had pointed out, accounting revenue
recognition rules were subject to judgment. And, in applying that judgment,
management could make decisions easily proven wrong by subsequent events. Of
course, clarity of hindsight didn’t necessarily mean the decisions were
improper.
What if he was
wrong? If O’Brian disclosed a change in accounting for revenue recognition at
this critical stage, the launch of BrainWave could be seriously compromised,
causing big problems for O’Brian’s future.
Nick stared at
his aunt, pondering his answer. Was he making a big deal out of a legitimate
practice? Or should he stick to his belief that O’Brian Software was smoothing
income?
Commentary on:
Conservative
Recognition or Cookie Jar Reserves?
Michael A. Santoro is an
Assistant Professor at the Rutgers Business School.
.jpg”>
“If there is one thing we have learned
in the post-Enron world, it is that CEOs can no longer claim that they don’t
understand their company’s accounting methods”.
Kudos to young
Nick for having the courage and savvy to raise a legitimate accounting question
to the highest levels of the company. Of course, it doesn’t hurt that his Aunt
Amelia runs the company (presumably with the title, as well as power, of the
chief executive officer). Realistically, it might be harder for a young person
just out of college to get the kind of attention for an accounting issue that
Nick has gotten at O’Brian. This is too bad because every company, even those
run efficiently and honestly, could use a good test of its ethical systems now
and then.
The good news
is that in this organization, when a young person–admittedly one related to
the boss–questions the company’s ethical practices he is taken seriously. Both
Lee and Aunt Amelia heard Nick out thoroughly and responded to his concerns
forthrightly. Regardless of how this problem is resolved, Nick has learned that
he can speak up when something is bothering him. The more experienced
executives in the company seem comfortable when they are challenged. Lee
doesn’t agree ultimately with Nick’s conclusions, but he is willing to defend
his actions when challenged. There is, moreover, a functioning audit committee and
an independent board of directors that would appear to act as a check on
management.
Nick’s
assertions that (1) “in effect” the company was understating in good times and
thereby building artificial reserves for lean times; and that (2) this practice
is misleading investors are certainly issues that ought to be taken up by the
audit committee. The fact that the BrainWave launch is imminent is irrelevant.
Ironically, what makes this a perfect issue for the audit committee is
precisely the fact that Aunt Amelia doesn’t have an opinion about it. She is,
in fact, wrong to put Nick in the position of deciding whether or not it should
go to the audit committee. Nick has done her a favor by calling the possible
problem to her attention, but she knows enough about the nature of the issues
to make her own judgment about whether they should go to the committee. Clearly
it should, because she is unsure herself about the propriety of the current
accounting methods.
Indeed, one
potential ethical problem within this company is Aunt Amelia’s professed lack
of knowledge about accounting. If there is one thing we have learned in the
post-Enron world, it is that CEOs can no longer claim that they don’t
understand their company’s accounting methods. Indeed, new federal legislation
requires the CEO to sign and acknowledge personal responsibility for the
company’s financial statements. Aunt Amelia clearly needs to devote more
attention to this aspect of her business or else turn over the CEO duties to
someone who will exercise appropriate oversight over O’Brian’s accounting
practices.
Presented with
the issue, the audit committee may or may not agree with Nick. Lee will have a
chance to defend his accounting methods. He will be able to show whether
relevant accounting rules allow the company discretion to present the deferred
revenue as it has done in the past. Certainly the fact that the company has
three years of public operating experience without any apparent surprises for
investors is encouraging. That suggests
that that the way the company is providing information may not, as Nick fears,
be misleading to investors. The audit committee can make a judgment about the
practice and, if necessary, seek the advice of the company’s independent
auditors. All in all, what we are witnessing in this case is how the corporate
governance system works when it is working well. Even if it turns out Nick’s
concerns about the company’s accounting don’t require restatement of the
financials, Nick is still to be commended for giving the company a chance to
check its corporate governance systems. Even honest people can sometimes make
ethical mistakes. Good corporate governance systems can help catch those
mistakes, and invoking the duties of an audit committee should not be viewed as
impugning the character or honesty of corporate officers.
Ms. Elizabeth Sanders is the
sole proprietor of E. A. Sanders, CPA.
“Using conservatism to build reserves for
hard times misstates income during a particular period and would mislead users
of financial statements”.
Are
the financial statements of O’Brian Software deceptive? Facts to consider:
Aunt Amelia O’Brian has no accounting expertise and is
interested in meeting projections and keeping the Wall Street analysts happy.
Aunt Amelia is perceived to be honest by the family.
The majority of the stock is owned by the family.
O’Brian Software went public three years ago and has
received a clean opinion from the outside auditors for each accounting year.
Accounting controls are considered effective.
Chief financial officer Lee Marchetti is perceived to
be honest and has many years of financial experience.
Marchetti was involved in the initial public offering.
In most cases,
it is a good thing to be conservative in the recognition of revenue.
Conservatism is part of the foundation of the accounting profession. However, using conservatism to build reserves
for hard times misstates income during a particular period and would mislead
users of financial statements.
To determine
if Marchetti is being overly conservative, Nick should examine what is included
in deferred revenue. He should determine if the numbers currently included in
the balance sheet are realistic. In reviewing the numbers in the deferred
accountings on the balance sheet, Nick should review software agreements with
customers.
Normally in
software agreements, a customer pays a fee to use software for a predetermined
period (for example, one to three years). When the sale occurs, recognition in
the financials would include entries to receivables and deferred revenue.
Revenue would then be recognized during the financial statement period when the
agreement is in effect, with entries between deferred revenue and revenue. Nick should determine if deferred revenue
accounts include dollars that apply to expired agreements. If that is the case,
Marchetti is using conservatism to smooth revenue and misstating revenue for a
particular period. This would create misleading and deceptive financial
statements. The Wall Street analysts may be happy with the constant growth, but
this is not realistic. Unfortunately,
the analysts’ influence may encourage such behavior.
Depending on
what Nick’s analysis of the deferred accounts determines, the launch of new
product may have to be delayed. If Nick determines that amounts in the deferred
accounts apply to expired agreements and are materially overstated (a judgment
call), he should recommend to Aunt Amelia that she notify the audit committee.
If the audit committee does not take a positive position to make adjustments to
the prior financial statements, Nick may have to notify the Securities and
Exchange Commission.
Robert O’Connor, President and CEO, Softrax Corporation
.jpg”>
“The burden of executive management does
not fall to him, and neither can he expect to abruptly change the way the
company runs because he has a suspicion”.
Smoothing
revenue is as illegal as any other revenue manipulation. Fundamental fiduciary
responsibility requires that full financial disclosure must occur, and
knowingly reporting inaccurate revenue is both unethical and illegal. But is
that what’s really happening here? Nick knows just enough to suspect a real
problem but not enough to definitely determine its existence on his own. The
complex multi-element contracts prevalent in the software industry are easy to
mishandle from a revenue allocation and reporting perspective. Is there an
error in the current internal controls, or is there intentional
manipulation?
It would
appear that a change in revenue recognition accounting procedures must be made.
The upcoming product launch cannot and should not impede that change. It must
be disclosed, regardless of the timing. For a publicly traded company, the
legal obligation is as strong as the moral imperative. But the chief financial
officer’s resistance to questions about his accounting judgment is quite
strong, and Nick cannot force a change. Neither should he attempt to without
understanding if, in truth, revenue is being smoothed. Does Nick understand the
full parameters of the guidance at play? Does he know where interpretation can
vary, and where the regulations are crystal clear? He needs to learn more.
My
recommendation to Nick is that he should begin by documenting his concerns in a
memo that he does not yet distribute. If he goes to the audit committee,
external auditors or the Securities and Exchange Commission, he needs to have
his facts and timeline in order. He must set about increasing his knowledge of
the regulations, getting outside opinions and receiving training from the CFO to
understand how the business runs. Then he needs to look at the financial
statements again.
After this due
diligence, if Nick is convinced that Lee is underreporting revenues and, in
effect, cooking the books, he must present that assertion in writing to his
aunt. Together they can decide what to do. But the burden of executive
management does not fall to him, and neither can he expect to abruptly change
the way the company runs because he has a suspicion. If he has documented
concerns and evidence, then real change must be brought about. The key to a
successful resolution will be Nick’s willingness to do his homework and to
involve his aunt.





