Postdated Check and Holder in Due Course Right: Check and
Funds Transfer Case
David was concerned about his brother-in-law, Gerald. Gerald
lost his job over two years ago, and he was not trying very hard to find a new
job. David decided to help Gerald out when Gerald could not meet his mortgage
last month. Sarah, Gerald’s wife and David’s sister, had been trying to make
the monthly payments. However, last month, Sarah told David that she just did
not have the money. David did not want to see Gerald and Sarah lose their home.
Therefore, he gave them the payment, $2,200, in cash. In return, Gerald gave
David a postdated check for this month. Gerald and Sarah assured David that
David could deposit the check because sufficient funds were available. Instead,
David signed the check over to Dan whom David owed $2,200 for personal
services. When Dan presented the check to the drawee bank, the bank refused to
cash it due to insufficient funds. Dan claimed that David still owed him the
$2,200. David refused to pay claiming this was improper because he was
protected as a holder in due course.
Is David correct? If so, what are his defenses?
Will Dan be successful? Discuss why or why not.





