Colored Island Fish and
Evolutionary Predictors
“You have been asked to study
two recently discovered fish species, both found in waters off a small island.
The two species are very similar in general structure, but there are two key
differences between them. In species A, males are brightly patterned with blue,
red, and purple scales, whereas the females are drab, and males are much larger
than females. In species B, males and females are the same size, and both are a
dull brown color that blends in with the sandy bottom. You have decided to do
an in-depth study of these two species. In order to get your research grant,
you must first develop some predictions about what you will find.”
After you read this scenario, I
would like for you to answer the following questions:
a. What differences in behavior do
you predict (list as many as you can think of)?
b. How might the evolutionary
histories of the two species differ





