Week 7 discussion
DQ1 DEATH IN WAR
Both Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried (pages 101–111)
and Randall Jarrell’s Death of the Ball Turret Gunner (page 550) describe a
death as a result of war. Yet each is remarkably different in the tone used to
describe that death. What are the differences in tone between these two works?
How do these differences affect what readers are to learn about the significance
of death in war?
DQ2 GRIEF IN
LITERATURE
Both Ben Jonson’s On My First Daughter (pages 550–551) and
Seamus Heaney’s Mid-Term Break (page 697) are about reconciling oneself to the
death of a child. How does each speaker reconcile himself to this death? Or
does he reconcile? Does either speaker draw any significance from this death?
Compare the attitudes expressed in these two poems with the attitudes about the
inevitable death of oneself as portrayed in Flannery O’Connor’s A Good Man is
Hard to Find (pages 484–493) and Emily Dickinson’s Because I Could Not Stop for
Death (pages 545–546). How is the grandmother’s behavior when confronted by her
own death in the O’Connor story different from the speaker’s attitude about her
own death in the Dickinson poem? Do any of these four works agree about the
significance of death to the living?





