Mom &
Pop’s 5 &
10
John Kern,
manager of
Mom and Pop’s
5 & 10,
is considering
how to
restructure the
check-‐out line
at their
Charleston, South
Carolina store.
The goal
is to
optimize the
staffing levels
and customer
service. At
present, each
of the five
clerks has a
separate waiting
line. During
the hours
between 5:00
PM and 7:00
PM Mr. Kern
collects data
on the
waiting lines.
He
calculates an
average of 90
customers per
hour enter
the lines,
but there is
no limit to
how many
customers can
enter the
lines. Also,
he collects
data on the
clerks’ checkout
times and
calculates an
average service
time to be
3 minutes per
customer.
To reduce the
amount of
time a
customer spends
in the
waiting line,
Mr. Kern
would like to
consider three
options for
restructuring their
checkout at
Mom and
Pop’s. First,
he would
like to
consider a
checkout line
for customers
buying five
or less
items. Past
receipts show
that 30% of
all customers
purchase five
or fewer
items per
visit, and
John recalls
that the
clerks averaged
a checkout
time of 2
minutes on
these customers.
If the
remaining 70%
of customers
entered the
four remaining
lines, average
service times
would increase
to 3.4
minutes because
each customer
in these four
lines would
check out
with a
greater number
of items.
The second
option would
be a
single-‐line system
where all
customers enter
the same
waiting line
and then go
to the first
available of
the five
clerks. This
option would
require John
to rearrange
or remove the
displays in
the front
section of
the store.
With this
option, John
also wants to
explore whether
it might
reasonable to
reduce the
number of
clerks to
four or
fewer.
The final
option to
consider is
adding an
automated checkout
station.
Mr. Kern
assumes the
same service
rate as going
through an
actual clerk’s
line, and he
estimates 20%
of their
customers would
use the
automated checkout
system. This
option would
also use a
single-‐line system
serviced by
clerks for
those customers
who require
(or desire)
full-‐service from
a checkout
clerk. With
this option
John could
choose to
continue to
operate with
five clerks,
but he hopes
to reduce the
required number
of clerks to
four.
Assignment
Mr. Kern asks
you, as
corporate’s operations
manager, to
analyze the
available data
and write a
report with a
recommendation from
the options
he presented.
He wants
to base his
decision on
the option
that provides
the “best
customer experience”
in his store.
After
discussing this
with him
further you
realize that
John believes
that customers
who spend the
least amount
of time
possible in
the checkout
line are the
ones who have
the “best
experience.”
Based on your
analysis, which
option should
Mr. Kern
choose?
Why?
Include all
of your
calculations and
charts as
appendices in
your report.
Where applicable,
refer to them
to help Mr.
Kern better
understand your
recommendation(s) and
conclusion.





