Module 1 case
Introduction to Graduate Studies
Assignment Overview
Module 1 provides an introduction to academic research,
writing, and referencing; and to samples of work in the field of business
ethics that may be helpful in supporting other assignments in this course.
In the Module 1 Case, a form of treasure hunt, you will be
exploring the online library (accessed on the bottom right of the TLC homepage)
for articles, books, and websites devoted to various topics in business ethics.
The assignment calls for providing end references, in-text citations, or
correctly referenced paraphrasing (putting a quotation into you’re your own
words) according to guidance indicated in one or the other of the required
reference identified below.
Case Assignment
Go to the online library, find the following items, and
provide the information requested.
Books
Business Ethics: A Stakeholder and Issues Management
Approach by Joseph Weiss, published in 2014, available in the EBSCO ebook
Collection.
What is the proper end reference – using APA Style – for
this book?
What is the end reference for Chapter 7 in this book?
Provide the first sentence in Section 2 of Chapter 3 (page
119). Then, using proper APA Style, cite this sentence in-text as a direct
quotation.
Paraphrase the first paragraph in Chapter 4, section 2,
under the heading, “The Corporation as Social and Economic Stakeholder” (page
183). (Figure 4.1 graphically captures its meaning.) Be sure to include the
proper (APA) in-text citation, e.g., Weiss (2014) claims…
B: Journal Articles
“Stakeholder Theory and a Principle of Fairness” by Robert
Phillips, published in 1997, available in ProQuest.
What is the proper end reference – using APA Style – for
this journal article?
Provide the first sentence the first paragraph of Section 5,
titled “Fairness and Consent” on page 58, and cite this sentence (in-text) as a
direct quotation.
Is the journal in which this article was published properly
defined as “scholarly?” How do you know? (Identify the criteria for scholarly
journals and indicate which ones are satisfied.)
C: Electronic Sources (e.g., Websites)
Locate the items identified in the URLs provided below and
indicate the proper end reference based on APA style
Websites – http://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/042915/how-low-can-oil-prices-go.asp
Periodicals –
http://www.forbes.com/sites/sebastianbailey/2013/05/15/business-leaders-beware-ethical-drift-makes-standards-slip/
Keys to the Assignment
The key aspects of this assignment that should be covered in
your paper include the following:
Don’t forget to include a Cover Page with your assignment!
Be sure that you answer each part of the assignment.
Number each question before responding. For example:
Part A
1.
2,
3.
4.
Part B
1.
2.
3.
Part C
1.
2.
Assignment Expectations
Assignments are graded based on a rubric that identifies
evaluation criteria and different levels of fulfillment from poor to excellent.
Criteria include satisfying requirements and expectations;
demonstrating critical thinking; the quality of responses to questions; the
quality of organization, writing (including grammar and spelling), and
presentation; the quality and diversity of references utilized; and the
adequacy of in-text citations and end references.
To learn how to access assignment grades and feedback, watch
the following video:
http://permalink.fliqz.com/aspx/permalink.aspx?at=b13c1b2c864344a68565357ea2f9f7ff&a=e635c1442edf4f4f9952a5d4ddef7bf0
Module 1 SLP
Introduction to Graduate Studies
In this initial SLP, you will use the The Student Guide to
Writing a High Quality Academic Paperguide to complete a sample paper in accord
with the formatting requirements you will use throughout your graduate degree
program.
Required Reading
To begin, please review The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper.
In addition to reviewing The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper, I would like you to briefly review Dr. Drummond
McNaughton’s guide for writing high-quality papers: Dr. Drumm’s Writing Tips.
Assignment
Complete the Sample SLP using The Student Guide to Writing a
High Quality Academic Paper.
Keys to the Assignment
Download the Module 1 SLP – Formatting Exercise paper. Then,
using The Student Guide to Writing a High Quality Academic Paper as a guide, do
the following:
Complete the Cover Page.
After you have read the paper, write an introductory
paragraph.
Insert appropriate titled section heading where requested.
Provide in-text citations where requested.
Write a concluding paragraph.
Properly format your end references, placing them in the
correct sequence.
Be sure to look for other formatting errors not noted above!
Save your completed paper, and upload your assignment before
the due date.
Optional Reading
APA Sample Paper. (2015). Purdue OWL. Retrieved from
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/media/pdf/20090212013008_560.pdf
SLP Assignment Expectations
At Trident University, your assignments will be evaluated
using grading rubrics.While every assignment is assessed using one of the
rubrics, grading rubrics may differ across assignments. Should you need help
locating the grading rubric for this SLP, be sure to watch the following video:
http://permalink.fliqz.com/aspx/permalink.aspx?at=b13c1b2c864344a68565357ea2f9f7ff&a=e635c1442edf4f4f9952a5d4ddef7bf0
Module 2 case
Since he is the world’s wealthiest man, it is not surprising
that Bill Gates is the subject of much controversy. As a businessman, he has
been described as brilliant and innovative on one hand but also as ruthless and
cutthroat in his business practices. Criticisms have included both the
atmosphere he created in the workplace as well as the tactics he has used to
try to beat his competitors. And while some have questioned the tactics he used
to become the world’s richest man, he is also donating a huge portion of his
fortune to charity. But his charitable activity has also been criticized as he
brings some of his business management style to his charity work.
You won’t have any trouble finding articles about Bill
Gates, but try to find several articles both positive and negative about him
and a balance of information both about how he has run Microsoft and how he has
run the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation or other charities. Compare and
contrast what you’ve read about him with the various virtues and vices that you
read about in the background readings such as Brusseau (2012) and Velasquez et
al. (2008). Think carefully about which virtues and vices apply to Gates’
business and charitable activities.
There is plenty of information on Bill Gates out there, but
here are a few articles to get you started on your research that will give you
some idea of the controversies surrounding the man:
McCullough, J. (n.d.) Bill Gates. Americans that matter.
Retrieved from
http://www.americansthatmatter.com/bill-gates/
McIlvaine, A. (2016, February 4). Bill Gates’ ruthless
management style of yore. HRE Daily. Retrieved from
http://blog.hreonline.com/2016/02/04/bill-gates-ruthless-management-style-of-yore/
Piller, C. (2014, August 24). How the Gates Foundation’s
investments are undermining its own good works. The Nation. Retrieved from
https://www.thenation.com/article/how-gates-foundations-investments-are-undermining-its-own-good-works/
Case Assignment
After doing some research on Bill Gates, choose at least two
virtues and at least once vice that are mentioned in Brusseau (2012) or
Velasquez et al. (2008). Also, make sure to thoroughly review the materials on
critical thinking in the background readings. It is very important to use
critical thinking in this paper, especially for Question 2. Once you have
finished your research on Bill Gates and are clear on what critical thinking
is, write a 4- to 5-page paper with the following:
State the virtues and vices that you will focus on, and give
the definitions of these virtues or vices using a reputable online dictionary
(e.g., http://www.merriam-webster.com/). Note that this part of the assignment
doesn’t require much critical thinking – you are just giving some definitions.
Using a section heading for discussion of each of your
chosen virtues or vice, discuss how each virtue/vice applies to some ethical
issue raised in your readings about Bill Gates. For example, you might want to
describe how Bill Gates lived up to these virtues or vices or how he might have
better handled a situation through use of one of these virtues. This is the
main part of the assignment and requires a lot of critical thinking. Don’t just
summarize information, instead explain based on the definition of each virtue
and vice how they apply to Bill Gates. And use information from the articles to
support the article. Don’t just blindly summarize information from the
articles, instead point out how specific actions by Bill Gates embody or not
embody the virtues and vices you have chosen to discuss. And remember to divide
your paper into clear sections with headings based on each of the virtues and
vices you are discussing.
Conclude your paper with one or two paragraphs giving your
overall evaluation of Bill Gates and his ethics. Any final thoughts on why a
“cutthroat” or “ruthless” business man also became one of the world’s most
generous philanthropists?
Assignment Expectations
Be sure to use at least two sources from the library to
support your discussion and analysis (choose sources that are not included in
the Background section of Module 2).
Follow The Student Guide to Writing a High Quality Academic
Paper guide.
Don’t forget to properly cite your sources—both in-text and
as end references!
You are expected to demonstrate evidence of critical thinking—as
defined in the readings above on critical thinking and the grading rubric.
Remember that this means your paper should not be just a summary of the
articles and book chapters that you read, but rather an expression of your own
opinions and analysis.
Module 2 SLP
For this assignment, first choose a controversial ethical
issue that interests you. This can be any controversial ethical issue as long
as you can find articles expressing opposing opinions on this issue. This issue
could be something from the business world such as drug-testing of employees,
Facebook gathering private information from their users, etc. Or you can also
choose other controversial issues such stem cell research, the death penalty,
etc. The purpose of this assignment is to apply some of the concepts of
critical thinking and argumentative writing from the background readings to an
ethical issue of your choice.
Once you have chosen the issue you want to write about, find
at least three articles on this issue including two articles that take opposing
views on this issue. Then write a 2- to 3-page paper that makes an
argumentative in favor of a position on this issue. You should not just
summarize the articles you found. Instead, choose the viewpoint you wish to
argue in favor of and use the information to support your point of view. Use
the template from the Classic Model for an Argument reading in the background
materials.
You don’t need to worry about whether or not your professor
agrees with your point of view. What you do need to focus on though is whether
or not your paper is just a summary of information (in which case your
professor will not give you a high grade) or is a genuine argumentative paper
where you make a solid case for your point of view on one side or the other of
a controversial issue. Your grade will be based on the quality of your
arguments and your ability to analyze rather than just summarize information
that you find.
SLP Assignment Expectations
· Be sure to cite articles in favor of each of the two sides
of the controversial issue you are writing about. Don’t choose a topic unless
you can find articles supporting both sides of the issue. You should cite at
least three articles total.
Follow the guidelines in The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper
You are expected to demonstrate evidence of critical
thinking—as defined in the Module 2 background materials and the grading
rubric.
Save your completed paper, and upload your assignment before
the due date.
Module 3 case
Few companies these days are as controversial for their
business practices as Uber. However, in spite of the negative publicity they
are a very widely used and growing service company that is replacing taxi cabs
and even leading some people to give up their own car in favor of using Uber to
get to work. The number of drivers also keeps growing.
There are too many controversies regarding Uber to keep
track of, so we will focus just on three that we will examine from a
utilitarian perspective. Below are three issues to look into for the
assignment, and a few articles to get you started on your research:
Uber uses money from investors to keep its prices very low.
They lose money on many rides, but they are willing to lose money to put the
competition out of business:
Wolsen, M. (2014, July 8). Uber’s brilliant strategy to make
it too big to ban. Wired. Retrieved from:
https://www.wired.com/2014/07/ubers-brilliant-strategy-to-make-itself-too-big-to-ban/
Uber classifies their drivers as contractors rather than
employees, which keeps labor costs down:
Frazier, R. (2016, October 14). Sharing is caring: Are Uber,
Lyft drivers independent contractors? HR Hero Line. Retrieved from:
http://www.hrhero.com/hl/articles/2016/10/14/sharing-is-caring-are-uber-lyft-drivers-independent-contractors-2/
Uber has allegedly used technology to evade the authorities
and regulations:
Isaac, M. (2017, March 3). How Uber deceives the authorities
worldwide. New York Times. Retrieved from:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/03/technology/uber-greyball-program-evade-authorities.html
For this assignment, you will be examining these practices
of Uber through the lens of utilitarian ethics. You will need to put aside any
personal feelings in favor or against Uber and instead take the cold and
logical approach of weighing the good caused by their practices vs. the harm
caused by their actions for each of the three issues above.
Case Assignment
Once you have finished reviewing the required background
readings on utilitarian ethics and corporate social responsibility and had a
chance to research the three issues on Uber mentioned above, write a 4- to
5-page paper addressing the following:
Who are Uber’s main stakeholders? Your answer should be
based both on your research on Uber and the discussion in Brusseau (2012) about
stakeholders.
Which stakeholders are harmed and which stakeholders benefit
from Uber’s strategy of using investor money to keep prices artificially low?
Does the good outweigh the bad, or vice versa? Apply the Utility Test:
http://ethicsops.com/UtilityTest.php
Which stakeholders are harmed and what stakeholders benefit
from Uber’s policy of classifying drivers as contractors rather than employees?
Apply the Utility Test and explain whether the good outweighs the harm or not.
Finally, discuss which shareholders are harmed and which
stakeholders are helped by Uber’s use of advanced software to evade
authorities? Again use the Utility Test and explain whether the good outweighs
the harm or not.
Assignment Expectations
Follow the guidelines in The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper.
Don’t forget to properly cite your sources—both in-text and
as end references!
You are expected to demonstrate evidence of critical
thinking—as defined in the background materials and the grading rubric. Don’t
just summarize information. Instead demonstrate your ability to come to a
conclusion and support your conclusion using logical arguments
Module 3 SLP
Normally people choose the product or service they purchase
based on finding the best quality for the lowest price. It is rare that
corporate social responsibility (CSR) plays a big role when most people decide
on where to take their business. However, Uber’s largest competitor Lyft is
trying to use the issue of CSR to lure customers away from Uber.
Review Chapter 13 of Brusseau (2012) on CSR, and do some
research on any attempts Uber and Lyft have made to improve their CSR. Here are
is an example of Uber’s claims to CSR from their webpage:
Shifting expectations: Finding better ways for cities to
move, work, and thrive. (2017). Retrieved from:
https://www.uber.com/helping-cities/
Likewise, here an example from Lyft’s webpage on their
claims to CSR:
Paving the way for greener cities. (2015). Retrieved from:
https://blog.lyft.com/posts/earthday
Finally, this article is critical of both Lyft and Uber
regarding CSR:
Griswold, A. (2017, March 3). Lyft might be “woke” compared
to Uber, but that’s a low bar. Quartz. Retrieved from:
https://qz.com/945304/lyft-ceo-john-zimmer-said-the-company-is-woke-maybe-compared-to-uber/
After you’ve finished reviewing Chapter 13 of Brusseau
(2012) and have done some research on Uber and Lyft (use the above articles
plus some other recent articles that you find), write a 2- to 3-page paper
addressing the following issues:
Evaluate Uber’s CSR efforts. Based on your research on Uber
as well as the various theories of CSR in Brusseau (2012), do you think their
CSR efforts are mostly hype or are genuine?
Evaluate Lyft’s CSR efforts. Based on your research on Lyft
as well as the various theories of CSR in Brusseau (2012) do you think their
CSR efforts are mostly hype or are genuine?
Overall, do you think their CSR efforts will lead either one
of them to greater success? Or do you think most consumers (including yourself)
will be more likely only to consider price and quality of service?
SLP Assignment Expectations
Follow the guidelines in The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper.
Don’t forget to properly cite your sources—both in-text and
as end references!
You are expected to demonstrate evidence of critical
thinking—as defined in the background materials and the grading rubric. Don’t
just summarize information. Instead demonstrate your ability to come to a
conclusion and support your conclusion using logical arguments
Module 4 case
Module 4 slp
For your final SLP, think about a major ethical dilemma you
faced in the past. Think carefully about how the notions of
utilitarian/consequentialist ethics and duty/deontological ethics from the
Module 3 and 4 background readings apply to this dilemma.
Then write a 2- to 3-page paper addressing the following
issues:
Briefly describe the ethical dilemma you faced.
How does the Utility Test apply to this ethical dilemma that
you faced?
What were the duty/deontological implications of this
ethical dilemma?
Based on the material from this class, might you have made a
different decision regarding this ethical dilemma if you could do it all over
again?
SLP Assignment Expectations
Follow the guidelines in The Student Guide to Writing a High
Quality Academic Paper.
Don’t forget to properly cite your sources—both in-text and
as end references!
You are expected to demonstrate evidence of critical
thinking—as defined in the background materials and the grading rubric. Don’t
just summarize information. Instead demonstrate your ability to come to a
conclusion and support your conclusion using logical arguments





